Part II - Product UI & User Experience

​

Critiquing the product UI and experience involves assessing how well the interface supports usability, functionality, and overall user satisfaction. A well-designed product should offer a seamless and intuitive experience, enabling users to accomplish tasks efficiently with minimal friction. This critique will examine key aspects such as visual design, interaction patterns, navigation flow, accessibility, and responsiveness across devices. By identifying strengths and areas for improvement, we can uncover opportunities to enhance usability, streamline workflows, and create a more engaging and user-centered experience. Both Instaproof and the larger overarching DataTrails UI were critiqued.

​​

https://app.datatrails.ai/instaproof

​​

What is the Product's Purpose?

​

Provides users with a clear, intuitive way to verify and track the provenance of digital content while minimizing friction in the process. The overall experience goals are efficiency, transparency and trust. The ideal DataTrails UI should be: Highly scannable → Users immediately recognize what’s verified, what’s at risk, and what they need to do. Actionable → Key functions (upload, verify, explore history) are obvious and easy to access. Visually structured → Strong hierarchy so important elements (verification results, provenance history) stand out.

​​

What Actions can Users Take?

​​

• Create and Manage Audit Trails: Users can initiate the process of creating audit trails by selecting digital content (documents, images, or other data types) and submitting them to the platform for verification. Users can upload files or link to external data sources to start tracking and securing their digital content. Once audit trails are created, users can track the changes made to the data and view its history of modifications, timestamps, and verifications.

• Search Audit Trails and Filter Results (Data): Users can search for specific audit trails by entering keywords or other identifiers to locate relevant data. The UI allows users to filter results based on different criteria, such as the date of creation, data type, verification status, or other metadata associated with the audit trail.

• View and Verify Data Integrity: Users can check the integrity and status of a particular piece of data or audit trail, ensuring that it has not been tampered with. For each audit trail, users can access detailed information about its verification history, including timestamps, involved parties, and verification statuses.

• Manage User Roles and Permissions: Admin users can manage roles and permissions for team members, granting them access to different levels of the platform (e.g., full access, view-only, or restricted permissions for specific data). The product UI provides functionality to invite new users, edit user roles, and assign specific permissions for access to various data or features.

• API Integration Management: Developers can generate and manage API keys for programmatic access to the platform, enabling them to interact with the system through the provided APIs. Users can configure integrations with external applications, platforms, or services to automatically create and manage audit trails within DataTrails.

• Monitor System Alerts and Notifications: The UI displays real-time system alerts, such as failed verifications, errors, or important updates to the platform. Users can set up their preferences for receiving alerts and notifications about system activity, such as data verification results or security updates.

• Access Documentation and Contact Support: Users can access detailed product documentation and guides directly within the UI to understand how to use the platform, troubleshoot issues, or integrate with other systems. If users face issues, they can contact support through integrated help options, including chat, email, or submitting a support ticket.

• Manage Account Settings: Users can update their personal or team profiles, including contact information, security settings, and notification preferences. Users can enable two-factor authentication (2FA), change their passwords, and adjust other security settings.

• View and Download Reports: Users can generate and download reports about the status of their audit trails, including summary reports, data integrity reports, and security-related reports. Users may also have the option to export data for further analysis or integration into other systems.

• Test and Experiment: Developers can interact with an API console directly in the UI to test API calls and see how the platform responds in real-time. Before committing to changes or creating audit trails, users can preview how the data will be displayed, verified, or processed within the system.

• Security and Privacy Management: Users can manage encryption settings for the data they upload, ensuring that it is securely stored and transmitted. The UI may provide users with the ability to review logs detailing who accessed specific data and when, ensuring transparency in access to sensitive data.

​​

What Strengths does the Product Possess?

​​

• Clear Value Proposition: The UI does a good job of making it clear what DataTrails offers: secure, verifiable, and traceable content. This focus is reinforced through minimalist design elements that keep the user engaged with the core function, rather than overwhelming them with unnecessary complexity. DataTrails' UI excels in providing clarity of purpose, simplicity in its workflows, and ease of use, especially when it comes to verifying and exploring data authenticity. These strengths ensure that users can easily navigate the platform without being overwhelmed by unnecessary complexity.

• Simple Onboarding Process: The UI offers two clear entry points—one for users wanting full functionality and another for those who just need to verify data. This tiered onboarding helps cater to a broad range of user needs without overcomplicating the experience.

• Simple and Secure Authentication: DataTrails handles sensitive data verification, the authentication process incorporates security best practices (e.g., two-factor authentication (2FA), secure login protocols, or OAuth integration). This ensures users can trust the platform with their data and verifies their identity before they can interact with critical features.

• User-Friendly Data Verification: Since the product’s main purpose is to confirm data provenance and authenticity, the UI does a great job of presenting results in an easy-to-understand format. This kind of transparency is essential to the product’s credibility. The interface seems to be designed with the assumption that users don’t need to be tech-savvy to verify data, offering a simple and non-technical view of provenance and authenticity.

• Visual Simplicity & Clean Design: The UI’s simplicity means it doesn’t overwhelm the user with too many elements, which can improve overall usability. A streamlined interface helps guide users through the process without unnecessary distractions.

• Efficiency: How quickly can users accomplish key tasks? Are there unnecessary steps or friction points? Key tasks, such as recording evidence into an immutable audit trail, are streamlined, allowing users to perform actions with minimal steps. Key tasks, such as recording evidence into an immutable audit trail, are streamlined, allowing users to perform actions with minimal steps.

• Efficient Data Uploading & Registration: UI for uploading data offers a clear and seamless process—with drag-and-drop features, clearly labeled actions, and success/failure messages. This reduces friction for users who need to quickly get data into the system.

• Streamlined Information Display: With a clear purpose and relatively straightforward workflows, the UI likely keeps the relevant information front and center, minimizing confusion and ensuring users quickly access the information they need (such as verification results or trail history).

• Visual Consistency: The UI maintains visual consistency across various pages and functions (e.g., the same buttons, color schemes, and fonts), it reinforces trust and creates a familiar, cohesive experience for users.

​

What Product UI & Experience Opportunities Exist?

​​

• Onboarding Experience - Consider adding more personalized onboarding based on the user's role and needs (for example, a walkthrough tailored to those only verifying data vs. those uploading and managing larger datasets). Tailoring the onboarding experience based on user roles or selected account types can make the process more relevant and engaging.

• NUF Interactive Tutorials: Implementing interactive walkthroughs or tooltips during the initial user interaction (NUF = New User Flow) can further demystify complex features, ensuring users can navigate the platform effortlessly shortly after initial entry to the UI. Additional JIT EDU (Just In Time EDUcation) would add value and clarity for the new user flow.

• Progress Indicators: Introducing visual progress markers during onboarding can help users understand their journey stage, reducing potential confusion.

• Visual Engagement: Incorporating more interactive elements or motion graphics could enhance user engagement and effectively convey complex concepts. Motion design opportunity here. Opportunity to establish secondary and tertiary accent colors to bring emphasis to particular messages, diagrams, and actions (buttons, links, etc).

• Reducing Clicks for Key Information: the main (core) view requires additional interactions to see essential details (like uploaded data, images, or provenance), it adds friction to the user flow. Users who are verifying data likely want to see immediate context without navigating deeper into menus. A zero-clicks interaction design, post digital content drag-and-drop, would add value here.

• Expanded Preview or Inline Details: Display key metadata (e.g., timestamps, source, verification status) directly in the main list/grid view rather than requiring a click. A hover-based quick view or an expandable row/card could help users see more details at a glance.

• Progressive Disclosure Instead of Extra Clicks: Instead of taking users to a new page (e.g. modal pop-up window), consider in-place expansion (accordion-style or inline overlays) to reveal more details without full navigation away from the main view (post drag-and-drop).

• Reducing Number of Modal Pop-ups: If deep details are necessary, offer side panels rather than full-page transitions. On-hover pop-ups may add value here. While keeping the UI clean is important, making users hunt (via extra clicks) for critical details could create friction. A well-structured, information-dense main view (without feeling cluttered) would be efficient.

• Customizable Views: Allow users to toggle between a compact view and a detailed view depending on their preference. This way, power users can see everything at a glance, while new users still have a clean interface.

• Contrast & Visual Hierarchy: Add contrast and "pop" in accent colors, navigation elements, and primary actions, this could lead to stronger visual guidance for users. When key elements don’t stand out, users may struggle with: Understanding Navigation → Where they are in the app, Recognizing Primary Actions → What they can do next, and Scanning Information Efficiently → What’s important vs. secondary. Primary, secondary and tertiary user action analysis can help here.

• Accessibility - Ensuring that the platform and product UI meets WCAG compliance standards would make it more accessible to users with disabilities. This includes providing text alternatives for non-text content and ensuring sufficient color contrast. This is of course always a great challenge for any product design and development team.

• Responsiveness: mobile device and desktop browser break point opportunities.

​